Rancho Cucamonga Residents Question Cost, Purpose, and Oversight of New Library Project

As plans move forward for a new library in Rancho Cucamonga, residents across the community are beginning to ask a series of practical questions about cost, priorities, and how the facility will function in today’s environment.

The project, estimated at approximately $28 million, is being presented as a modern, multi-purpose community space. While many residents appreciate investment in public amenities, others are asking:

Is this the right project at the right time?
And does it reflect how people actually use libraries today?

David VanGorden, candidate for Rancho Cucamonga City Council District 2, campaigning the incumbent Kristine Scott, says these conversations are growing.

“This isn’t about being for or against libraries,” VanGorden said. “It’s about making sure we’re making decisions that align with how residents live today—and what they need most.”

From Books to “Library of Things”

One of the more talked-about features of modern libraries is the expansion into a “Library of Things,” where residents can check out items such as kitchen appliances, tools, and other equipment.

While the concept is innovative, it has also raised practical concerns:

• How are these items tracked and maintained?
• What systems are in place to ensure they are returned in working condition?
• What are the ongoing costs associated with replacing or repairing them?

“Residents aren’t questioning the idea,” VanGorden said. “They’re asking how it works day-to-day and what it ultimately costs over time.”

Liability and Safety Questions

Some residents have also pointed to potential liability issues when lending out certain types of equipment.

If an item is used improperly and someone is injured, where does responsibility fall?
What protections are in place for both residents and the City?

VanGorden says these are common-sense questions that deserve clear answers.

“Anytime you expand services into areas that involve physical equipment, safety and liability naturally become part of the discussion,” he said.

Is the Library Still the Center of Community Life?

City messaging has described the new library as a central gathering place for the community.

However, some residents are asking whether that reflects current behavior.

Are residents using libraries the same way they once did?
Or have community needs shifted toward other priorities?

“People are asking whether this type of facility still serves as the hub it once did,” VanGorden said. “It’s a fair question in today’s world.”

Balancing Costs with Core Needs

With ongoing concerns about traffic, infrastructure, and public safety, some residents are weighing the library project against other needs.

“When you’re talking about a project of this scale, it’s reasonable to ask how it fits into the bigger picture,” VanGorden said.
“Are we addressing our most pressing challenges first?”

Encouraging Open Discussion

VanGorden is encouraging residents to take part in the conversation and share their perspectives.

“The goal isn’t to criticize,” he said. “The goal is to ask thoughtful questions and make sure residents feel heard before decisions are finalized.”

About David VanGorden

David VanGorden is a candidate for Rancho Cucamonga City Council, District 2. His campaign focuses on listening to residents, asking practical questions, and promoting transparency in local decision-making. You can ask questions or express concerns by clicking Contact David VanGorden Here.